Does Fair Always Mean Equal When Making a Will?
When making a Will, it is easy to assume that treating family members fairly means dividing an estate equally. In this episode of the Barnard Lawyers Podcast, lawyer Ian Barnard explains why that is not always the case and what Western Australians should consider when deciding how their estate will be distributed.
Ian explains the concept of testamentary freedom, which allows a Will-maker to decide who receives their assets and in what proportions. For some families, equal shares may make sense. In others, financial circumstances, previous support, caring responsibilities or family relationships may influence what the Will-maker considers fair.
If you are considering your own estate arrangements, Barnard Lawyers provides advice on Wills and estate planning.
Key Points From the Podcast
00:00 | When fair does not necessarily mean equal
Ian introduces one of the difficult questions that can arise when preparing a Will: whether every child or beneficiary should receive the same share of an estate.
02:45 | Does a Will have to be divided equally?
The podcast explains that a Will in Western Australia does not automatically need to provide equal shares to children or other beneficiaries. Ian introduces testamentary freedom and what it means when deciding how assets should be distributed.
04:15 | What can influence the way an estate is divided?
Different financial needs, previous assistance and the nature of family relationships can all form part of a Will-maker’s thinking.
05:30 | The potential for disputes
Unequal distributions can create tension, particularly where a beneficiary receives less than expected or does not understand the reasons behind the decision. Ian highlights why careful consideration and documentation matter when making these choices.
07:55 | What might a fair distribution look like?
The episode gives practical examples, including recognising a child who has sacrificed work to provide care, considering the circumstances of a beneficiary living with a disability, or accounting for substantial financial assistance previously given to one child.
09:45 | Blended families and stepchildren
Ian also considers the additional decisions that can arise in blended families and why Will-makers may need to think specifically about how they want different family members provided for.
You can learn more about Ian Barnard and Barnard Lawyers on the About Barnard Lawyers page.